Just found this very helpful link on Jerry Coyne's blog of the accommodation debate or free-for-all from last June. This is the episode started by Coyne with his New Republic article on Miller and Giberson that I mentioned a few posts back. Here's another link at edge that essentially has the same material some way down the page.
Wilkins on the great accommodation debate.
This link to an article by Blackford on Wilkins seems to belong here.
This will be useful to me, if no body else, so I've posted it here for easy reference.