Just found this very helpful link on Jerry Coyne's blog of the accommodation debate or free-for-all from last June. This is the episode started by Coyne with his New Republic article on Miller and Giberson that I mentioned a few posts back. Here's another link at edge that essentially has the same material some way down the page.
Wilkins on the great accommodation debate.
This link to an article by Blackford on Wilkins seems to belong here.
This will be useful to me, if no body else, so I've posted it here for easy reference.
Showing posts with label Mooney. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mooney. Show all posts
Monday, June 28, 2010
Sunday, June 27, 2010
Episode n+1
Jen McCreight of Blag Hag blog posts about an a symposium devoted to accommodationism at the Evolution 2010 conference to which no anti-accommodationists were invited. Apparently atheists are the mirror image of creationists.
Ophelia Benson weighs in.
Jerry Coyne as well.
The inimitable PZ Myers of Pharyngula has a crack.
Russell Blackford too.
For the other side:
You're not helping having a crack at Jerry Coyne. And commenting on Chris Mooney article that's in the previous post. I guess this episode (n+1) isn't discrete from n.
Ophelia Benson weighs in.
Jerry Coyne as well.
The inimitable PZ Myers of Pharyngula has a crack.
Russell Blackford too.
For the other side:
You're not helping having a crack at Jerry Coyne. And commenting on Chris Mooney article that's in the previous post. I guess this episode (n+1) isn't discrete from n.
Episode n of the debate
I'll just post this set of links. If you are a follower of the accommodation debate you'll be familiar with the parties involved and possibly with these particular articles.
First up we had a pro argument in the Huffington Post by Alan I. Leshner, CEO of the AAAS.
Then an anti discussion at Ophelia Benson's Butterflies and Wheels. Some good comments there IMO.
Russell Blackford enlarged on the discussion on his Metamagician blog.
John Pieret critiques Blackford on his (Pieret's) Thoughts in a Haystack blog.
That's where I lost the trail on this episode of the debate. I'm sure there were more posts on blogs.
[EDIT] Update, discovered more spore and picked up the trail!
Chris Mooney, riffs on Ishners HuffPo piece at the Intersection blog.
Ophelia Benson was not amused.
Russell Blackford elaborated on a cracking comment by Eric MacDonald (commenting on the previous link's article) on Butterflies and Wheels. Even if you violently oppose Eric's views, you've got to admit the man can write!
Jerry Coyne critiques Chris Mooney. I need some form of tree diagram to show the linkage here!
You're not helping critiques Coyne. Plenty of snark.
First up we had a pro argument in the Huffington Post by Alan I. Leshner, CEO of the AAAS.
Then an anti discussion at Ophelia Benson's Butterflies and Wheels. Some good comments there IMO.
Russell Blackford enlarged on the discussion on his Metamagician blog.
John Pieret critiques Blackford on his (Pieret's) Thoughts in a Haystack blog.
That's where I lost the trail on this episode of the debate. I'm sure there were more posts on blogs.
[EDIT] Update, discovered more spore and picked up the trail!
Chris Mooney, riffs on Ishners HuffPo piece at the Intersection blog.
Ophelia Benson was not amused.
Russell Blackford elaborated on a cracking comment by Eric MacDonald (commenting on the previous link's article) on Butterflies and Wheels. Even if you violently oppose Eric's views, you've got to admit the man can write!
Jerry Coyne critiques Chris Mooney. I need some form of tree diagram to show the linkage here!
You're not helping critiques Coyne. Plenty of snark.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)